Key takeaways
- Chips: Usually about $2–$3 and the simplest low-cost side.
- Cookies: Commonly about $2–$4 each, with flavors varying by location.
- Pickles or small snack sides: Often around $2–$4 where offered.
- Shared sides: Availability and pricing vary considerably, so check the individual restaurant menu.
The 2026 Potbelly menu with prices typically runs from about $5–$8 for soups and sides, $8–$13 for sandwiches, $9–$14 for salads, and $2–$5 for drinks and desserts, with exact totals varying by city, size, tax, and delivery channel.
Potbelly menu with prices at a glance
| Menu category | Typical 2026 price | Serving details | Best choice when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original-size sandwich | $8–$11 | One toasted sandwich; usually enough for a light-to-moderate lunch | You want a standard individual meal |
| Big-size sandwich | $10–$13 | Larger portion with more filling and bread | You have a substantial appetite or are skipping sides |
| Salad | $9–$14 | Full entrée salad; protein and toppings vary by recipe | You prefer a lower-bread meal |
| Soup | $5–$8 | Small or regular bowl, depending on location | You want a lighter meal or a sandwich pairing |
| Side | $2–$5 | Chips, cookies, or another small accompaniment | You need a modest add-on |
| Fountain drink or bottled beverage | $2–$4 | Size and beverage selection vary by restaurant | You are building a complete combo |
| Shake or dessert | $4–$7 | Single dessert serving; availability can be limited | You want a more filling treat |
These are planning ranges rather than a guaranteed national price list. Potbelly prices can differ between downtown locations, suburban restaurants, airports, and licensed venues. Delivery menus may also show higher item prices or separate service and delivery charges.
Sandwiches: the main decision
Potbelly’s core menu is built around toasted sandwiches served in an Original or Big size. The Original is generally the better value for a normal lunch, while the Big size makes more sense when the sandwich is your entire meal or you want leftovers.
| Sandwich | Typical price range | Flavor and filling profile | Who should choose it |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck | $9–$13 | A hearty combination of multiple deli meats with cheese and standard toppings | Hungry diners who want the most substantial deli-style option |
| Italian | $9–$13 | Italian-style cured meats, cheese, and savory toppings | People who prefer a salty, traditional sub profile |
| Turkey Breast | $8–$12 | Leaner sliced turkey with customizable toppings | A lighter sandwich or a simpler order |
| Turkey Club | $9–$13 | Turkey with bacon and additional sandwich toppings | You want turkey but need more richness |
| Mediterranean | $8–$12 | Vegetarian ingredients with Mediterranean-style flavors | You want a meat-free sandwich with pronounced seasoning |
| Meatball | $9–$13 | Warm meatballs, sauce, and cheese | You want a hot, saucy comfort-food meal |
| Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad | $8–$12 | Chilled salad filling with lettuce and sandwich toppings | You prefer a softer, cold sandwich texture |
| Veggie Melt | $8–$12 | Warm vegetables and melted cheese | You want a hot vegetarian option |
For a balanced order, choose an Original sandwich plus soup or a small side. Choose the Big size only if the additional bread and filling solve a specific need; otherwise, the upgrade can be less cost-effective than adding a separate side for sharing.
Salads, soups, and sides
Salads
Potbelly salads commonly include options such as Farmhouse, Powerhouse, and other location-dependent combinations. Expect leafy greens, vegetables, cheese or grains, dressing, and sometimes chicken or another protein. Most entrée salads fall in the $9–$14 range. A salad with protein is usually more filling than a basic side salad, but dressing and toppings can materially change the calorie and price profile.
Soups
Soup availability changes more often than the sandwich menu. Commonly seen choices include Classic Tomato, Garden Vegetable, Chicken Pot Pie, and Broccoli Cheddar, although not every restaurant carries every variety every day. Plan on about $5–$8 for a serving.
Soup is the practical add-on when you want variety without ordering a Big sandwich. A sandwich-and-soup combination is usually more satisfying than a sandwich with a small packaged snack, while a soup-only order works best for a lighter lunch.
Sides
- Chips: Usually about $2–$3 and the simplest low-cost side.
- Cookies: Commonly about $2–$4 each, with flavors varying by location.
- Pickles or small snack sides: Often around $2–$4 where offered.
- Shared sides: Availability and pricing vary considerably, so check the individual restaurant menu.
Drinks and desserts
Fountain drinks and bottled beverages generally cost $2–$4. Coffee, lemonade, iced tea, and other specialty beverages may sit toward the upper end of that range. A shake or more substantial dessert often costs $4–$7. If you are ordering for several people, beverages and desserts can add more to the bill than expected: four $3 drinks add $12 before tax, while four $5 desserts add $20.
| Order scenario | Likely food total per person | What it includes |
|---|---|---|
| Budget lunch | $10–$14 | Original sandwich plus chips or a basic drink |
| Standard full meal | $13–$19 | Original sandwich, soup or side, and a drink |
| Large appetite | $14–$21 | Big sandwich plus drink or side |
| Salad meal | $12–$19 | Entrée salad and drink |
| Meal with dessert | $17–$26 | Main dish, drink, and shake or dessert |
Which Potbelly order fits your situation?
| Your situation | Recommended order | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Small appetite | Soup or Original sandwich with a light side | Avoids paying for a Big sandwich that may be more food than you need |
| Very hungry | Big A Wreck, Italian, or Meatball sandwich | Prioritizes filling ingredients and a substantial portion |
| Vegetarian | Mediterranean, Veggie Melt, or a salad | Provides meat-free choices, subject to local ingredient availability |
| Lower-bread preference | Protein-based entrée salad | Places vegetables and toppings at the center of the meal |
| Family or office order | Original sandwiches with shared sides and separate drinks | Makes portions easier to mix and usually controls the total better than all Big sandwiches |
| Strict budget | Original sandwich, skip dessert, choose water or a basic drink | Limits upgrades and add-ons, which are the fastest way to raise the bill |
Regional variation and how to check the final price
Before placing an order, select the exact Potbelly location rather than relying on a generic menu search. Check the listed size, included toppings, soup availability, beverage format, and whether the menu is for pickup or delivery. Prices shown through delivery services may not match in-store prices, and promotions may apply only to particular restaurants or ordering channels.
Also check substitutions carefully. A premium protein, extra cheese, additional topping, shake, or larger drink can add to the displayed base price. For a reliable budget, allow roughly 10% for local sales tax and another 15%–30% or more for delivery-related charges when applicable.
Bottom line
The best value on the Potbelly menu with prices is usually an Original sandwich paired with one modest side or soup. Choose a Big sandwich for appetite rather than habit, select an entrée salad when you want a vegetable-forward meal, and verify the local menu because soups, desserts, toppings, and prices vary by restaurant.
